Tuesday, October 24, 2023

Sherlock Holmes and The Abergavenny Murder

    In The Adventure of the Priory School (1904), Dr. Huxtable requests Holmes come to his school in Mackleton. Holmes shakes his head and says, “My colleague, Dr. Watson, could tell you that we are very busy at present. I am retained in this case of the Ferrers Documents, and the Abergavenny murder is coming up for trial.” 

Now fans can discover the mystery of The Abergavenny Murder in Holmes of Baker Street.

Here is the opening to The Abergavenny Murder.

If there was a man who had earned the reputation as the foremost expert on crime, that man was, indeed, Sherlock Holmes. The London detective would have been the first to admit that this distinction was only too true. It was not that Holmes was boastful or arrogant, it was simply that he  believed in his own talent and abilities, and to overestimate or underestimate either would not be truthful or accurate. He was often obsessed with truth and accuracy. 

    He made it a point to study not only the history of crime but also recent criminal acts at home and abroad. Holmes personally stayed in contact with police detectives in several countries around the world—from Belgium to Brazil and from Cameroon to Canada. In his catalogue of crime, there were hundreds of modes of murder, robbery, kidnapping, confidence games, blackmail, forgery, and others. He went to great lengths to collect newspaper clippings of crimes and for each, he made comprehensive notes calling attention to certain details of the case. This would allow him to hear the features of a more recent crime, and make a conclusion based on the study of similar cases, not unlike a doctor who listens to the symptoms of a patient and accurately diagnoses the illness. But Holmes was not a doctor, nor was he a private detective; he was a consulting detective, perhaps the only one in the world. He was the man that detectives went to see when they were in a fog, or over their heads regarding a case. 

    To aid him in his work, Holmes studied human beings and was very aware of human foibles and vices, and things that motivated people. I would not classify Holmes as a lover, but he knew that love was a strong emotion that could easily lead a man or woman to perform acts they would not normally do if that emotion was not involved. Though he seldom demonstrated them himself, Holmes understood human emotions such as fear, vengefulness, hatred, and greed, and how these emotions led to criminal acts.

    He continually acquired vast amounts of specialized knowledge. Holmes would sometimes say; A man should keep his little brain-attic stocked with the furniture that he is likely to use, and the rest he can put away in the lumber-room of his library, where he can get it if he wants it.   

    However, Holmes had also once said that it was not possible for a man to possess all knowledge, so he endeavoured to store up a great deal of knowledge that aided him in his work. He was well up on human anatomy, chemistry, and psychology. He made a comprehensive study of tobacco ash, bicycle tires, printed type, handwriting, tattoos, old documents, and secret codes.

    But of course, he fell short of possessing all knowledge. Even the Encyclopedia Britannica did not possess all knowledge.

    It was early in May 1901 and Holmes, and I had just finished our lunch. It was a beautiful spring day, but the weather was of little interest to Holmes, who sat around restlessly in his mouse-coloured dressing gown, his gray eyes mere slits, and his chin sunk upon his chest. For months on end, the great detective had had little with which to scintillate his brilliant mind. ‘Trivialities and stagnation’ was the phrase he uttered almost daily. 

    “Nothing in the papers, Watson?” he said, his gaze fixed upon the ceiling. 

All of Stephen Gaspar's books can be found on Amazon!